The GSD notes that Mr Picardo is unwilling to be subjected to any form of scrutiny on how he is utilising £275 million of net cash raised from mortgaging the six housing estates and instead choses to treat Parliamentarians with contempt and attack them personally.
Roy Clinton the shadow minister for public finance said:
“Mr Picardo’s display of contempt for my person is as lamentable as it is laughable. Being unwilling to explain where the £275 million has gone, for which he is responsible as Minister for Finance, he now tries to undermine my credibility as he might with an expert witness in court.
For the record then, I am a Fellow of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (FCA), a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Bankers (FCIB) an Associate Member of the Association of Corporate Treasurers (AMCT) and a member of the Chartered Institute for Securities and Investment (MCSI). I also have a degree in Commerce (BCom) and a degree in Financial Services (BSc). All of which I think proves me far more qualified in finance than Mr Picardo or anyone in his cabinet with or without honorific titles.
He suggests in his press release that in Viewpoint last year I said I would have done the Gibraltar Capital Assets £300 million transaction myself and that it was good money. Mr Picardo may have wished I had said that and puts words into my mouth to that end in a cheap trick, but what I said could never be construed in that way and Viewpoint on 16 February 2017 on the £300 million can be watched on replay on GBC’s website (see minutes 08.47; 21.58; 39.21 and 45.25).
As regards mixing capital and expenditure this is all that I said on Hansard on 2 July 2018 as regards the University:
“..the accounts for the University of Gibraltar for 31st July 2017 are not finalised – and yet we are being asked to approve a tripling in its budget to £1.5 million in 2019 – a tripling, and we have no sight of their financial statements.”
It was in fact his Government who mixed the recurrent expenditure on the consolidated fund with that of capital already expended through the Improvement and Development Fund. So much so, since I had no right to reply, that I tweeted during the Budget session on 3 July 2018:
“Minister for the University needs to attend one of its accountancy courses. Doesn’t know difference between capital spend and recurrent expenditure. Last years capital spend was £1.4 million and £500,000 recurrent expenditure. This year estimated recurrent spend is £1.5 million!”
Mr Picardo is wriggling on his self-made £275 million hook and the more he struggles to bury me and my public finance questions the more desperate and ridiculous he becomes. This is transparency and democracy Picardo style, Gibraltar deserves better in a Chief Minister.”
The GSD notes that the Chief Minister is again doing his best to avoid answering what he has done with the £300 million raised by mortgaging the six housing estates.
Roy Clinton the shadow minister for public finance said:
“I am becoming accustomed to the Chief Minister avoiding answering any simple questions in respect of public finance such as what has he done with the net £275 million raised from the mortgage of six housing estates or even how he proposes to pay for the new schools for which only £1,000 was provided for in this years Budget.
The Chief Minister has however now conceded that the £300 million is a “structured liability” in other words a loan and thus not an “investment” as he once claimed. The Chief Minister cannot deny that if Gibraltar Capital Assets Limited defaults on its obligations the Government will defacto have to pick up the bill. This crushing debt burden will be borne by future generations thanks to this Government’s reckless thirst for borrowing none of which was mentioned in their 2015 manifesto.
The Chief Minister has also admitted that the 3% annual rent increase was part of the financial modelling underlying the financing deal. This confirms what we were told at the meeting with his technical experts on 6 February 2017. It is not insignificant because compounded over a 31 year period a 3% annual rent increase would result in £61.5 million of additional revenue to the company which would be needed to repay its debts.
I have no need to lie or pretend otherwise and I challenge the Chief Minister to make public the private placement memorandum on the issue of the company’s loan notes as well as the put option agreement.
We still do not know what has been done with this money or how much of it remains and I again ask the Chief Minister to answer the £300 million question namely what has he done with it? The people of Gibraltar deserve complete transparency on these important matters which the Chief Minister continues to refuse to provide. The Chief Minister falls well short of what we should expect of a Finance Minister and I regret we will only know the whole truth once we have a change of Government.”
Mortgage Company Files Accounts but Government fails to explain use of £300 million
The GSD notes that following questions and pressure in Parliament the Government owned company that mortgaged the six housing estates for £300 million has now filed its full 19 page audited accounts at Companies House.
Roy Clinton the shadow minister for public finance said:
“I am pleased to note that following questions in Parliament on 31 May 2018, Gibraltar Capital Assets Limited has now filed full audited accounts at Companies House replacing the single page previously filed.
These accounts show in detail how the housing estates have been mortgaged for 31 years at a transaction cost of £4,642,420 and that the annual rental income of £3 million representing 3,083 flats is collected by the Government and paid to the company. It also confirms that the Government underwrites the £300 million loan notes in the event of a default by the company under the terms of an option agreement that the Government will still not disclose to the Opposition.
The Government cannot deny that this £300 million mortgage is a debt of Gibraltar and will crush any future Government’s ability to spend under the weight of this debt burden.
What I find particularly worrying is that the Chief Minster has still not disclosed what the net proceeds of £275 million are being used for as this does not come before Parliament in the Budget. Indeed the only information that the Chief Minister gave in the last Budget session was that £30 million had been used to inject more capital into the Gibraltar International Bank. The remaining £245 million remains unaccounted for in what can only be described as a disgraceful state of affairs and a complete lack of transparency.”
“If the GSD were in government at this crucial point when we are facing the unprecedented need to renegotiate our relationship with the EU we would have formed a cross party negotiating team. Our offer to assist the Government in the public interest was genuine and constructive. If the Government want to go it alone it is their prerogative. There was no need to ridicule the offer.” Said GSD Leader Keith Azopardi.
It is now increasingly clear that Mr Picardo thinks he is infallible. That is a dangerous feature in any politician and precedes a downfall. The Government’s latest press release on Brexit is just one of a pattern of press releases where its standard reply to criticism is that everyone else except it is wrong. The GSD analysis on the latest Brexit developments was measured, largely directed at the UK and entirely reasonable given where Gibraltar is right now. In reply the Government has reacted so defensively and nervously that it must be worried it is exposed.
Additionally the latest comment ridiculing the GSD offer to present a joint negotiating platform on Brexit as “pretentious” or adding nothing is the height of arrogance and shows how far the Government is willing to go in taking risks with Gibraltar’s future rather than present a united front at such difficult times.
Mr Azopardi said: “United fronts are not new. Politicians of different parties came together in the 1960s when Gibraltar faced threats at the United Nations, the 1970s in talks with Spain and when the 2006 constitution was negotiated. This is no different or important a moment. It is a recipe for disaster but regrettably no longer surprising that Mr Picardo is singularly unwilling to listen to other political voices.”
As we have repeatedly said we have expressed our willingness to assist. If the Government do not wish to take up an offer it is up to it to carry the can if things go wrong. We cannot help if we are never shown any internal papers or invited to have a genuine participation in negotiations alongside Government as a real and effective partner. One sided briefings are not the equivalent of real participation. We are in the final stretch and the reality is that beyond the platitudes the UK have given we have received nothing concrete to make us think that our future has been secured. We hope that despite all that Gibraltar emerges with an appropriate and effective long-term arrangement at the eleventh hour. At this stage, however, and two years after the referendum we have precious little to show for it. It would be more productive if instead of hitting out at the Opposition the Government focussed its energy on the UK Government and put more pressure on it. They should in the words of Nick Clegg, the former Deputy Prime Minister be “ferocious” in defence of Gibraltar. Instead they are looking like Mrs May’s poodles. We cannot imagine the GSLP of Sir Joe Bossano ever facing that criticism. If there is a Party that is a shadow of its former self in that regard it is the GSLP.
The GSD has today expressed disappointment that the Redibike scheme has performed so poorly in its first year of operation. The party has been monitoring the schemes usage throughout the year through questions in Parliament and while the figures were consistently low, accepted Government’s view that Redibikes should be given some time to be assessed.
Figures published last week showed that the average daily usage averaged fewer than five journeys per day which at a cost of £12000 per month cost nearly £90 per journey, a figure which certainly does not represent value for money to the tax payer.
Trevor Hammond, GSD spokesman for the environment and transport said “Government withdrew the previous Gibibike scheme claiming that it was an expensive mistake and then announced their own Redibike scheme before the last election in 2015. They said they would be ready by early 2016 though it took until May 2017 to become operational. The Minister, from the very beginning was at pains to point out the scheme was sponsored, never mentioning the costs and thus implying that these were negligible. It now transpires that the scheme is costing £12000 a month and it must be asked, in view of the extremely low uptake, whether this is value for money.
“Minister Balban has regularly pointed out how the previous Gibibike scheme was a failure, despite its similarity to the current scheme and despite giving that scheme less than a year to mature. It is hard to see how the Redibike’s which he has introduced after much delay having tried to distract attention from the cost can be described as a success when it is clear that they have proven to be an expensive flop.
“The success of the schemes such as these depends on a holistic approach to a transport policy and continuity between administrations, bringing together many elements at the right time. The GSD is committed to implementing other aspects such as the introduction of cycle lanes, improved awareness and incentives for alternative transport.”
A judgment of the Court of Appeal this week shows that the Chief Minister, Fabian Picardo misinformed Parliament in a debate that led to the passing of the Housing (Amendment) Act 2013, which the Court has declared interferes with constitutional rights.
This law extended the rent control regime to a wider but limited number of tenancies. It reduced rents of these few tenants from £500 to between £100 and £150 per month, a reduction of about 70%.
The Judgement finds that, in the parliamentary debate, the Chief Minister:
* said that certain provisions “should have been repealed as they were superfluous”, which contradicted an earlier finding of the Supreme Court;
* did not explain the reason why the Government was promoting the change in the law contained in the amendment;
* did not say why he wished to remove the difference between properties built between 1945 and 1959;
* did not clarify why in the Government’s view the amendment was for the benefit of the public;
* was not being accurate when he implied to Parliament that the amendment would ‘put matters right’;
* did not explain what social policy underlay the amendment;
* did not spell out the only effect of the amendment in manner that “a transparent democratic practice would usually require.”
The GSD acknowledges that it supported that change in law based on the Chief Minister’s explanations. It transpires that these were inaccurate, fell short of clarification and lacking in sufficient debate.
The GSD recognizes that Paul Balban, an affected tenant and then Minister for Housing, is said not to have participated in any decisions involving this change and to have voluntarily not taken up the reduced rent.
While Mr Paul Balban appears properly not to have sought to take the benefit of this measure, it calls into question why the Government thought it was wise to proceed with it when it could expose itself to the very criticism that the Court of Appeal has now made to the effect that “It is worrying that one of the limited class of people who could (emphasis added) benefit from this windfall was the Minister for Housing.”
This is pertinent when the amended law reverses the earlier decision of the Supreme Court against Mr Balban, on an Appeal from the Rent Tribunal, by which he had sought, in 2008 (before he was a Minister), to have the rent of his flat reduced to a controlled fixed rent.
These matters are at their core about good government and as to how the Government should exercise its powers.
The GSD notes that the Government intends to produce a command paper on abortion probably by the end of the summer. The Government has stated that that command paper will consult on amendments to the Crimes Act.
It remains to be seen to what extent the Government are envisaging changes to the existing law on abortion.
This is an issue that requires the utmost care. The recent judgment of the UK Supreme Court which seems to be motivating a desire by Government to contemplate changes in the law was hardly a unanimous endorsement that there should be wide-ranging changes in Northern Ireland. The judgment was mixed and only reached by a slim majority of 4-3. The judges also recognized that the Northern Irish law pursued a legitimate aim of protecting the life, health and welfare of the unborn child. Only in very restricted and defined extreme circumstances of fatal foetal abnormality, rape or incest did the court, by majority, think the law was too restrictive in Northern Ireland. The Judgment is not an endorsement of abortion on demand.
The GSD does not consider that decisions on this issue should be taken by Government or by Parliament in haste. The production of a command paper within a short period of weeks is far too accelerated on an issue such as this.
The GSD has been considering this issue for some months. It is undertaking its own consultation process to conclude its own policy consideration in this important area. The GSD has already met the Pro-Life Movement and has requested to meet the Pro-Choice lobby to consider the views of both groups. GSD Leader Keith Azopardi has formed a sub-committee of the Party which will table recommendations for the Party’s Executive. It will also consider any Command Paper issued by Government and any changes in the law the Government is contemplating.
“This is an issue deserving of the most serious and careful consideration. We make no apologies for thinking this process should not be hurried. At this stage we have not yet reached the point at which we are ready to make any policy announcements but we will do so in coming months as necessary. Additionally we make clear that if what is eventually proposed by Government is not, in our view, appropriate or in the public interest we would not support such changes” said Keith Azopardi.
Over the last five years, the GSD Opposition has been pressing the Government on the unprecedented numbers of agency workers within the public service, including the civil service. I myself have raised the issue in parliament on twenty separate monthly meetings because I feel it is a practice that exploits workers, distorts and hides true unemployment numbers, blocks vacancies and progression within the public service and has a detrimental effect on service users by (amongst other things) having an adverse effect on continuity of care. In my opinion, it is a huge blot on the Government’s socialist credentials.
Public interest
This also an area of business, which is very lucrative, and involves the expenditure of significant amounts of taxpayer’s money where the allocation of contracts are a matter of significant public interest. For example, we have seen recently formed Agencies, such MedDoc, being awarded significant contracts, which have involved the absorption of large parts of the trained workforce of Grand Home Care, an Agency which has been active in the sector for much longer. The only real asset of some of these recruitment Agencies, particularly in areas such as the GHA and the Care Agency are their trained staff. They spend a lot of time, money and effort training people. Stripping one Agency of its contract(s) with Government in favour of another, which then has the consequence of transferring large parts of the former’s workforce is like transferring an entire business. It is a matter of genuine public importance which has to be scrutinised.
Union outcry
The situation on the use of Agency workers in the public service has become so blatant that Unite the Union issued a bulletin in April stating that “morale has hit an all-time low” and “agency workers taking over directly employed vacancies, not being properly advertised”. The subsequent walk out from the GHA showed that even Unite had reached the end of their tether. It is not an issue that only affects the GHA, the Care Agency or the ERS; it is an issue that is causing concern across Government departments both for supply workers and for the public service.
In 2015, just before the General Election and to great fanfare, the Chief Minister announced the advertisement of AA vacancies within the civil service. These vacancies were not filled and instead what we have seen, is the introduction of efficiency measures within the public service. If the Government has spent too much money over its first term in office, and are attempting reel back on that spending then they should say so. It needs to be transparent with people as to the real state of the public finances and why it is not prepared to open vacancies to the public but is content to allow Agency workers to fill those vacancies on a long term basis. What the Government cannot do, is claim its management of public finances has produced record surpluses and income but then allow the exploitation of workers in their own departments, authorities or agencies.
Messages from the public
These are some of the redacted messages that I have received over the last few weeks which I want to share with readers so that they can understand first hand why people are so concerned about the current situation:
“Danny my daughter has been employed in the [Department] through [Agency] for more than three years … There are another [x] persons in the same situation … I have decided to notify you of this fact through private message, as my daughter as well as myself fear that repercussions may be taken by this administration”
“I’ve been working for agency for over three years … earning £6.75 an hour government staff same position as me nearly £9 an hour”
“I work for the [Department] … for almost 3 years and I am a supply worker we are many, some almost five years on supply”
“Danny I have been working in [Department] through [Agency] for more than 3 years. I have had had no holiday leave and my wage is just above the minimum wage for the same job as permanent staff are doing”
The common denominator in these (and other) complaints are that people are being kept on long term supply in the public service, on the minimum wage or near enough to it, without the same sick and holiday benefits that their permanent and pensionable counterparts receive.
The 2012 Regulations
Yet further, the sheer numbers of representations we receive reiterating the same complaints suggests that even basic legal protection is being ignored.
For example, the Agency Workers Regulations were introduced in 2012 to implement European legislation protecting agency workers from exploitation. Regulation 6, provides that an agency worker is entitled to the “same working and employment conditions” as they would have been entitled to for doing the same job had they been recruited by the hirer (in this case the Government or its emanations) rather than using the services of an agency provided workers who have worked in the same role with the same hirer for 52 continuous calendar weeks. As regards “working and employment conditions” this includes, among other things, pay (but not statutory or contractual redundancy entitlements) and annual leave.
While regulation 10 contains “Anti-Avoidance” provisions to guard against hirers or agencies structuring the arrangement to deliberately deprive a worker of his entitlements the testimony of so many agency workers who claim to have been working within the public sector continuously over 52 weeks on inferior terms to their public servant counterparts for doing the same job, is so compelling and frequent, that either the law is not protecting people or is not being respected.
GSD commitments
The GSD is committed to ensuring that workers get fair deal and that means closing loopholes in the law that allow Agencies and emanations of Government to place people in the public service for years on inferior and exploitative terms.
In preparation for our manifesto we are setting up a working group of lawyers, workers, former public servants and trade unionists to reform the 2012 Regulations and to also examine closely the profits made by Agencies at taxpayer and worker expense. We want to work with Unions and workers to get our policies right.
People should not be working on close to the minimum wage, without holiday entitlement for a number of years while colleagues employed permanently doing the same job are on far better terms.
Likewise, vacancies, if they exist, should be advertised and if they are not because we cannot afford it, things need to be explained honestly and transparently. It is, however, not right for someone to be permanently employed for years on supply terms. Either there is or there isn’t a job.
We are also committed to ensuring unemployment figures are truly reflective of unemployment in Gibraltar. While above I talk about workers who are working in the public service continuously for several years on supply terms,
there are also those employed by Agencies on zero hour contracts but are classified as “employed”. These are people who may have an employment contract, but they are certainly not employed in a meaningful way.
Together with our policies on training and rehabilitation of offenders, the GSD is working hard to develop policies which we hope you will not only find attractive but will treat people (especially our young) fairly, which is what we believe the people of Gibraltar want.
GSD asks Ministry of Justice to make greater strides in rehabilitation of offenders
The GSD notes statements made by the Chief Minister that this will be a BREXIT budget, by which we understand that this will be a prudent and cautious budget.
The GSD believes that there are measures that could be introduced in the area of rehabilitation of offenders where for a relatively modest cost, the community could benefit both socially and economically. It will be recalled that the GSD Government introduced legislation in relation to rehabilitation of offenders, which enables some convictions to become spent and, therefore, not have to be disclosed to prospective employers. In its Prison reforms the GSD Government also introduced mandatory drugs testing as part of the prison and parole process. In other words, the Parole Board as part of a prisoner’s release on licence can impose the condition that the released prisoner have periodic drugs tests in order to ensure that the prisoner remains clean. It is a great shame that these latter provisions had not been deployed at all prior to last year. It is time not only to ensure that these legislative provisions are used for the benefit of prisoners and society, but to take further steps to help the rehabilitation of offenders and the prevention of re-offending in future.
We would like the Minister for Justice to place education and training at the heart of that strategy on rehabilitation. That means assessing the educational and training levels and needs of prisoners at the point of incarceration and preparing clear, but individually tailored, programs to help prisoners acquire the skills they need to facilitate post release integration into society. It involves a holistic approach where judges, probation officers, the prison service and the Government work closely to ensure people come out of prison with a better chance of making an honest and useful contribution to society than when they were convicted.
It is a fact that a high number of offenders have no or a low numbers of GCSEs, A-levels or vocational training. Coupled with criminal convictions, that places them at a considerable handicap in the labour market which makes it more likely for them to reoffend.
The Ministry of Justice in the UK, has recently reviewed its policy on the rehabilitation of offenders, recognising the link between the lack of employment and educational opportunities with an increased risk of offending and the cost in both human and economic terms that entails. Measures that are being considered in the UK are greater assessment of prisoner’s education needs through, for example, sentencing plans at the point of sentencing that provide a clear direction on what a prisoner will require in order to help him or her improve her training and education while in prison. The UK Government is also securing partnership programmes with the private sector and charities (supported by tax credits) that enable employment and training in prison and on day release. Indeed, prisoner apprenticeship programmes are also being considered for an entire year after a prisoner is released. The Government already has the Future Job Strategy in place and that could be used to ensure prisoners are properly trained as a part of a holistic and early strategy aimed at more effective rehabilitation of offenders and integration in society.
Further, the GSD also note the Ban the Box international campaign by civil rights groups aimed at persuading employers to remove from their hiring applications for non-sensitive posts, the check box that asks if applicants have a criminal record, instead asking about this later in the application or recruitment process. This would at least allow offenders to be interviewed and make a positive impression before they are disregarded out of hand. The GSD believes this to be a worthwhile initiative for certain offences and one which the Government should consider consulting the public, unions and business about.
The reality is that despite legislative changes since 2011 there is still a great stigma associated with the hiring of former offenders. Lack of education, training and jobs contributes to re-offending with all the cost associated with the same. The time is right to prioritize these issues and attempt to end the cycle of reoffending.
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.